1. Andros Island
At the top of the list of ‘Top 5 Most Secluded Islands in the Bahamas’, is Andros Island. Andros Island is the largest island in the Bahamas, located in the western part of the archipelago. Positioned between the Atlantic Ocean and the Tongue of the Ocean, Andros spans approximately 2,300 square miles, making it the fifth-largest island in the Caribbean.
The island is characterized by its vast, unspoiled landscapes, which include extensive pine forests, mangrove swamps, and expansive wetlands.
Historically, Andros Island has been inhabited by the Lucayans, Arawaks, and later the British. The island played a significant role in the development of the Bahamian sponging industry during the 19th and 20th centuries.
Today, Andros is known for its rich biodiversity, particularly in the Andros Barrier Reef, one of the largest barrier reefs in the world.
Discover the Andros Barrier Reef (One of the Largest in the World)
Andros Island’s sparsely populated areas contribute to its secluded feeling, making it an ideal destination for yacht charters seeking a more private experience. While the island lacks the bustling nightlife and commercialism found in other Bahamian destinations, it offers a serene escape with its pristine beaches, lush landscapes, and opportunities for a diverse range of outdoor activities.
The island offers numerous cays and islets, with tons of secluded anchorages and private exploration. The vast Andros Barrier Reef, stretching over 140 miles, is a highlight for divers and snorkelers, showcasing vibrant coral formations and diverse marine life. The Tongue of the Ocean, a deep oceanic trench, adds to the allure for those interested in deep-sea fishing.
2. Cat Island
Cat Island, situated in the central Bahamas, is known for its serene and laid-back atmosphere, making it an appealing destination for a secluded yacht charter experience. With a land area of approximately 150 square miles, Cat Island offers a quieter alternative to the more frequented Bahamian islands.
The island’s history dates back to the Arawak and Lucayan Indian settlements, and it later became a haven for pirates. Cat Island earned its name from the infamous pirate Arthur Catt, who used the island as a base for his operations during the 18th century.
Hike to the Old Hermitage at the top of Mount Alvernia
Located at the top of Mount Alvernia, the tallest point in the Bahamas, you will find the Hermitage.
This small stone church, designed to resemble a medieval monastery, was built by Father Jerome, also known as John Hawes, a Catholic priest and architect from England.
Constructed in the 1930s, the Hermitage was a testament to Father Jerome’s dedication to solitude and spiritual reflection.
Father Jerome chose the site on Mount Alvernia to be closer to nature and to create a place of quiet contemplation.
The name “Alvernia” is derived from a mountain in Tuscany, Italy, associated with the life of St. Francis of Assisi.
The journey to Mount Alvernia and the Hermitage leads along a well-maintained trail to the summit, where hikers are rewarded with breathtaking panoramic views of the surrounding landscape and the stunningly clear waters of the Bahamas.
Swim with the Mermaids in the 600 ft deep inland Blue Hole
Another attraction of Cat Island is the fantastic Blue Hole, also known as ‘Mermaid Hole’.
This sinkhole is a natural geological phenomenon and a common feature of many of the Out Islands.
However, this particular hole, situated inland and surrounded by lush vegetation, is especially unique.
The Blue Hole on Cat Island is renowned for its remarkable depth, clear blue water, and diverse marine life.
Its depths extend hundreds of feet below the surface (possibly more than 600 feet), attracting divers and researchers interested in studying its geological features and the ecosystems it supports.
The water’s clarity allows for excellent visibility, making it a popular destination for underwater exploration.
As the name suggests, folklore tells a legend of Mermaids residing in the caverns in the lake’s depths.
These stories contribute to the area’s mystique and may serve as cautionary tales to discourage certain activities around the site.
Talk to a Yacht Charter Expert
Top 5 Bahamas Motor Yachts Under 55k Reviewed by Marcelle Hailwax
Read More3. Long Island
Long Island, situated in the southern part of the Bahamas, stretches approximately 80 miles in length, making it one of the longest islands in the Bahamas.
It is characterized by a mix of sandy beaches, rocky coastlines, and rolling hills. The island is relatively narrow, with the Atlantic Ocean to the east and the Caribbean Sea to the west.
Long Island in the Bahamas has a rich history that spans centuries. The Arawak and Lucayan Indians were the earliest known inhabitants, followed by the arrival of Spanish explorers.
During the 17th century, British colonists, primarily from Bermuda, settled on the island, establishing plantations.
The island gained historical significance as it was believed to be one of the first places Christopher Columbus visited during his exploration of the New World in 1492. Columbus Point on Long Island is associated with this historical event.
Today, Long Island has become a sought-after tourist attraction due to its many attractions and natural wonders both above and beneath the water. Below, you will find a list of the highlights of Long Island.
Highlights of Long Island
- Dean’s Blue Hole: Long Island is home to Dean’s Blue Hole, the world’s second-deepest blue hole. A popular spot for divers, it plunges over 600 feet into the ocean floor and offers a unique underwater experience.
- Cape Santa Maria Beach: This pristine beach on the northern tip of the island is renowned for its powdery white sand and turquoise waters. It’s an ideal spot for relaxation and water activities.
- Stella Maris Resort: Stella Maris Resort, located on the island, provides a tranquil retreat with accommodations, dining, and access to various outdoor activities.
- Clarence Town: The capital of Long Island, Clarence Town, is a charming settlement with colorful buildings, a historic church, and a laid-back atmosphere.
- Columbus Point: This scenic overlook offers breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean and the Caribbean Sea. It is said to be the first landfall of Christopher Columbus in the New World.
- Dunmore’s Cave: Located near Clarence Town, Dunmore’s Cave is a historical cave with Taino Indian petroglyphs. It provides a glimpse into the island’s indigenous history.
4. Inagua Island
Located in the southernmost part of the Bahamas, only about 55 miles from the eastern tip of Cuba, the Inagua Islands are the furthest Bahamian islands from Nassau.
Not as easy to get to as most other destinations in the Bahamas, they offer a secluded and pristine escape for those seeking a quiet yacht charter experience away from the usual tourist crowds.
Comprising Great Inagua and Little Inagua, these islands offer a unique blend of natural beauty and historical significance.
Great Inagua, the larger of the two, is characterized by vast salt flats, extensive wetlands, and untouched beaches. Little Inagua, an uninhabited paradise, complements its larger counterpart with its unspoiled landscapes.
Discover Inaguas' fantastic Wild Life such as the West Indian Flamingos
The dominant feature of Great Inagua is the Matthew Town Salina, one of the largest saltwater lakes in the Caribbean.
The island is also renowned for its flourishing bird population, including the West Indian flamingos that inhabit the Inagua National Park.
Approximately 80.000 Flamingos inhabit the island, outnumbering the human residents 6 to 1. The Flamingos thrive in the Island’s extensive wetlands and wild bush alongside parrots, Inagua hummingbirds, herons, egrets, roseate spoonbills, and wild donkeys, goats, and boars.
Inagua has a historical legacy tied to the salt industry, with remnants of salt evaporation ponds and old saltworks scattered across the landscape.
This industry, dating back to the 19th century, has left an indelible mark on the island’s cultural and economic history.
Talk to a Yacht Charter Expert
Top 10 Bahamas Motor Yacht Charters with 5-Star Client Reviews
Read More5. The Berry Islands
The Berry Islands, a cluster of 30 islands and more than 100 cays, stand as a testament to the pristine and secluded beauty that characterizes the Bahamas.
Located to the northwest of Nassau, this archipelago remains largely untouched by the bustling tourism that dominates other regions.
Renowned for its tranquility and unspoiled landscapes, the Berry Islands offer a serene escape for those seeking isolation in the heart of the Caribbean.
Their seclusion is due not only to their limited transportation options but also to the absence of major resorts and commercial development.
Enjoy endless exploration around the Berry Islands' many Cays
Attractions on the Berry Islands are predominantly centered around the natural wonders of the archipelago. Chub Cay, one of the larger islands, is renowned for its crystal-clear waters, making it a haven for snorkelers and divers.
The Great Stirrup Cay, owned by Norwegian Cruise Line, provides an opportunity to explore white sandy beaches and engage in water-based activities such as kayaking and paddleboarding.
Little Whale Cay, a private island available for exclusive rentals, offers an intimate and luxurious experience. With its own airstrip, this retreat caters to those seeking the utmost privacy.
The island features stunning beaches, vibrant coral reefs, and diverse wildlife for a truly immersive escape.
For history enthusiasts, the Great Isaac Cay Lighthouse stands as a prominent landmark.
Constructed in the 1850s, this historic lighthouse offers panoramic views of the surrounding ocean and is a testament to the maritime heritage of the Bahamas.
Ready to Start Planning Your Bahamas Yacht Charter Vacation?
To ensure you get the best experience, our brokers provide a curated shortlist of top Bahamas charter yachts tailored to your needs. They’ll share previous client reviews, walkthrough videos, and firsthand insights on yacht condition and crew, ensuring you book with confidence.
Types of Charter Yachts in the Bahamas
We recommend either chartering a motor yacht or catamaran for your crewed yacht charter vacation in the Bahamas. Why? The water in the Bahamas is very shallow, which greatly limits accessibility for deep-drafted yachts.
“We have seen a growing demand for luxury motor yacht charters among high-end charter guests.”