Bahamas vs BVI: Rated Best Yacht Charter Destination in 2025

The Setting: Tropical vs Sandy Oasis

According to our captains, the Bahamas offers a level of remoteness and raw beauty that’s hard to match. The Exumas in particular are a maze of untouched cays, quiet anchorages, and surreal turquoise shallows.

By contrast, the BVI is lush, compact, and more developed, with lively beach bars, restaurants, and well-worn cruising routes. It’s a fantastic place to start for first-time charterers — but for those looking to disconnect and explore somewhere less commercialized, the Bahamas wins.

Sailing Style: Easy Island Hopping vs Open Adventure

The Bahamas is literally more than 12 times larger than the British Virgin Islands and cannot be explored in a single charter trip, no matter the speed of your yacht.

Sailing in the BVI is about simplicity. The islands are close together, the waters are protected, and navigation is mostly line-of-sight. It’s ideal for shorter itineraries or guests who want minimal time under sail.

The Bahamas, on the other hand, demands a bit more from the captain — but rewards guests with long stretches of peaceful cruising and a sense of real exploration. As one of our crew put it, “You feel like you’re actually discovering something in the Bahamas.”

Experiences: Busy Beach Bars vs. Remote Natural Wonders

In the BVI, the social scene is a big part of the charm. From jumping off the Willy T to sipping Painkillers at Soggy Dollar, you’re never far from a rum punch and reggae music.

In the Bahamas, it’s a different kind of experience. With only a few beach bars across the Exumas, the focus shifts to swimming with pigs, diving blue holes, paddleboarding glassy channels, or simply soaking in the quiet beauty of your own private cove.

Charter Costs & Tax Differences

One of the biggest differences between the Bahamas and the BVI is not just where you go — but how you charter.

In the BVI, the most common option is a budget-friendly, all-inclusive catamaran charter, often starting around $15,000 per week. It’s a great setup for families or first-timers looking for an easy, social sailing experience with everything included.

In contrast, the Bahamas is a high-end charter destination. The distances between islands are longer, which makes motor yachts, power cats, and luxury crewed catamarans more suitable. You’ll find all-inclusive options too, but the experience is tailored and more exclusive — think fewer crowds, custom itineraries, and remote anchorages.

We typically recommend a minimum budget of $40,000 for a quality Bahamas charter. That allows for the right vessel, experienced crew, and provisioning to make the most of this unique cruising ground.

• BVI: Typically all-inclusive, with no tax. Easy and predictable.

• Bahamas: Uses the “plus expenses” model, where you pay a base rate plus 4% tax, 10% VAT, and an APA to cover fuel, food, and activities.

While that might seem more complex, it allows for customization and often results in a more personalized experience. And as one captain told us, “Guests in the Bahamas feel like it’s worth every bit — because what they’re getting is rare.”

Why the Bahamas Comes Out on Top in 2025

From speaking with seasoned captains who’ve chartered in both regions, the trend is clear: more guests are asking for the Bahamas. They want fewer crowds, more nature, and a deeper sense of escape.

It’s not the easiest place to charter — but that’s part of the appeal. It’s unfiltered, untamed, and unforgettable.

Final Word: Which One’s Right for You?

• If you’re looking for lively beach bars, short sails, and a social vibe — the BVI delivers.

• If you’re craving seclusion, stunning scenery, and a one-of-a-kind experience — the Bahamas is the destination of 2025.